Fri September 10, 1999
- FINAL/12Mariners4Orioles5
- FINALAthletics7Rays2
- FINALBlue Jays6Tigers7
- FINALMarlins2Reds4
- FINALRed Sox3Yankees1
- FINAL/13Cubs4Astros6
- FINALRangers3Royals7
- FINALAngels4Twins2
- FINALGuardians14White Sox6
- FINALBrewers3Rockies15
- FINALPirates5Cardinals11
- FINALPhillies1D-backs3
- FINALNationals3Padres10
- FINALMets1Dodgers3
- FINALBraves4Giants2