Tue September 14, 1999
- Game 1FINALAngels8Royals6
- FINALCubs4Reds3
- FINALRed Sox12Guardians3
- FINALAthletics6Orioles13
- FINALMariners5Rays1
- FINALYankees10Blue Jays6
- Game 2FINALAngels6Royals5
- FINALMets2Rockies7
- FINALRangers5Twins4
- FINALPhillies2Astros12
- FINALTigers7White Sox0
- FINALBrewers4Cardinals1
- FINALPirates1D-backs2
- FINALBraves11Padres4
- FINALMarlins0Giants3
- FINALNationals3Dodgers0