Wed September 22, 1999
- FINALCardinals3Cubs5
- FINALTwins5Athletics4
- FINALD-backs11Rockies3
- FINALGuardians9Tigers1
- FINALAstros2Pirates3
- FINALNationals5Marlins3
- FINALWhite Sox4Yankees5
- FINALBlue Jays14Red Sox9
- FINALMets2Braves5
- FINALOrioles7Rangers4
- FINALPhillies12Brewers3
- FINALReds4Padres3
- FINALRoyals12Mariners6
- FINALGiants5Dodgers4
- FINALRays5Angels8