Fri April 23, 2004
- FINALMets1Cubs3
- FINALGuardians3Tigers17
- FINALReds6Pirates4
- FINALPhillies8Nationals6
- FINALRed Sox11Yankees2
- FINALBlue Jays3Orioles11
- FINALBraves6Marlins1
- FINALMariners8Rangers10
- FINAL/10Rays2White Sox3
- FINALCardinals1Brewers2
- FINALTwins7Royals5
- FINALAstros13Rockies7
- FINALAngels12Athletics2
- FINALPadres2D-backs5
- FINAL/12Giants4Dodgers5