Tue May 4, 2004
- FINALRed Sox6Guardians7
- FINALRockies4Nationals10
- FINALRoyals4Blue Jays5
- FINALCardinals6Phillies5
- FINALWhite Sox3Orioles10
- FINAL/11Dodgers4Marlins3
- FINALGiants2Mets6
- FINALBrewers6Reds2
- FINALPadres2Braves4
- FINALD-backs6Cubs3
- FINALPirates3Astros4
- FINALRays5Rangers4
- FINALTigers4Angels11
- FINAL/16Twins3Mariners4
- FINALYankees10Athletics8