Wed May 12, 2004
- FINALBlue Jays3Royals4
- FINALGuardians6Red Sox4
- FINALAthletics2Tigers1
- FINALAngels11Yankees2
- FINALBraves2Cardinals5
- FINALRangers9Rays8
- FINALMarlins5Astros2
- FINALNationals3Brewers4
- FINALMariners3Twins4
- FINALMets1D-backs0
- FINALReds1Padres2
- FINALCubs0Dodgers4
- FINALPhillies3Giants4
- TBDOriolesWhite Sox
- TBDPiratesRockies