Tue May 18, 2004
- FINALTwins3Blue Jays5
- FINALDodgers7Phillies8
- FINALWhite Sox4Guardians2
- FINALAstros9Marlins2
- FINALBrewers2Nationals3
- FINALRockies8Reds3
- FINALCardinals4Mets5
- FINALRed Sox7Rays3
- FINALD-backs2Braves0
- FINALGiants1Cubs0
- FINALRoyals7Rangers6
- FINALTigers5Athletics1
- FINALOrioles7Mariners2
- FINAL/11Yankees0Angels1
- TBDPadresPirates