Tue May 10, 2005
- FINALPirates5Giants2
- FINALGuardians4Angels5
- FINALNationals2D-backs3
- FINALBraves9Rockies5
- FINALDodgers9Cardinals8
- FINALMets0Cubs7
- FINALTigers4Rangers5
- FINALPhillies5Brewers8
- FINALWhite Sox6Rays7
- FINALPadres1Reds5
- FINALRoyals1Blue Jays3
- FINALAthletics2Red Sox3
- FINAL/10Twins6Orioles4
- FINALAstros2Marlins6
- FINALMariners4Yankees7