Tue May 17, 2005
- FINALAngels5Guardians13
- FINALCubs4Pirates3
- FINAL/11Rays3Tigers4
- FINALCardinals5Phillies7
- FINALBrewers8Nationals2
- FINALReds1Mets2
- FINALD-backs0Astros3
- FINALRangers2White Sox5
- FINALOrioles12Royals8
- FINALBlue Jays10Twins3
- FINALGiants4Rockies9
- FINALRed Sox7Athletics5
- FINALBraves2Padres3
- FINALYankees6Mariners0
- FINALMarlins5Dodgers14