Tue May 24, 2005
- FINALMariners2Orioles3
- FINAL/11Twins6Guardians3
- FINAL/10Phillies3Marlins4
- FINALTigers3Yankees12
- FINALRed Sox6Blue Jays9
- FINAL/14Nationals3Reds4
- FINALAthletics4Rays5
- FINALMets0Braves4
- FINALAstros2Cubs4
- FINALRoyals3Rangers4
- FINALRockies1Brewers6
- FINAL/12Pirates1Cardinals2
- FINALPadres9D-backs5
- FINAL/11White Sox2Angels1
- FINALDodgers3Giants5