Fri September 16, 2005
- FINALCardinals3Cubs5
- Game 1FINALReds8Pirates2
- Game 2FINALReds4Pirates5
- FINALRoyals1Guardians3
- FINAL/10Athletics2Red Sox3
- FINALYankees11Blue Jays10
- FINALBraves0Mets4
- FINALRays6Orioles1
- FINALPhillies13Marlins3
- FINALMariners3Rangers5
- FINALBrewers1Astros2
- FINAL/10White Sox2Twins1
- FINALRockies6D-backs5
- FINAL/12Tigers6Angels7
- FINALNationals5Padres1
- FINALDodgers4Giants5