Fri April 24, 2009
- FINALRangers5Orioles4
- FINALTwins5Guardians1
- FINALNationals3Mets4
- FINALBraves4Reds3
- FINALPhillies7Marlins3
- FINAL/11Yankees4Red Sox5
- FINALBrewers5Astros2
- FINALTigers1Royals6
- FINALBlue Jays14White Sox0
- FINALCubs3Cardinals4
- FINALDodgers6Rockies5
- FINALGiants5D-backs1
- FINAL/11Pirates3Padres4
- FINALMariners8Angels3
- FINALRays8Athletics2