Sat May 2, 2009
- FINALCardinals1Nationals6
- FINALMarlins1Cubs6
- FINALAngels8Yankees4
- FINAL/11Orioles4Blue Jays5
- FINALAstros5Braves1
- FINALGuardians7Tigers9
- FINAL/10Mets5Phillies6
- FINALRockies5Giants1
- FINALReds6Pirates8
- FINALD-backs4Brewers1
- FINALRed Sox10Rays6
- FINAL/11Royals10Twins7
- FINALWhite Sox6Rangers9
- FINALAthletics3Mariners2
- FINAL/10Padres1Dodgers2