Thu May 7, 2009
- FINALBraves4Marlins2
- FINALPirates2Cardinals5
- FINALMariners1Royals3
- FINALGiants8Rockies3
- FINAL/10D-backs3Padres4
- FINALRangers4Athletics9
- FINALTwins4Orioles5
- FINALRays8Yankees6
- FINALGuardians3Red Sox13
- FINALPhillies5Mets7
- FINALBrewers5Reds6
- FINALCubs8Astros5
- FINALTigers0White Sox6
- FINALBlue Jays1Angels6
- FINALNationals11Dodgers9