Sun May 10, 2009
- FINALBraves4Phillies2
- FINALTigers5Guardians3
- FINALPirates4Mets8
- FINAL/10Cardinals8Reds7
- FINALYankees5Orioles3
- FINALPadres5Astros12
- FINALRangers7White Sox1
- FINALCubs4Brewers2
- FINALMariners5Twins3
- FINALMarlins2Rockies3
- FINALRoyals3Angels4
- FINALBlue Jays5Athletics0
- FINALNationals8D-backs10
- FINAL/13Giants7Dodgers5
- FINALRays3Red Sox4