Sat May 16, 2009
- FINALAstros4Cubs5
- FINALPhillies8Nationals5
- FINAL/11Twins4Yankees6
- FINALWhite Sox1Blue Jays2
- FINALBrewers1Cardinals0
- FINALMets9Giants6
- FINALGuardians2Rays4
- FINALAngels3Rangers5
- FINALDodgers3Marlins6
- FINALD-backs12Braves0
- FINALPhillies7Nationals5
- FINALAthletics1Tigers9
- FINALRockies4Pirates7
- FINALOrioles3Royals2
- FINAL/16Reds5Padres6
- FINALRed Sox5Mariners3