Wed June 3, 2009
- POSTPONEDMetsPirates
- FINAL/11Cubs3Braves2
- FINALRed Sox10Tigers5
- FINALRangers4Yankees2
- FINALAngels8Blue Jays1
- FINALRoyals0Rays9
- FINALBrewers9Marlins6
- FINALRockies4Astros6
- FINALGuardians10Twins1
- FINALAthletics5White Sox3
- FINALReds9Cardinals3
- FINALPhillies5Padres1
- FINALD-backs0Dodgers1
- FINALOrioles2Mariners3
- TBDGiantsNationals