Fri June 19, 2009
- FINAL/10Guardians7Cubs8
- FINAL/11Blue Jays1Nationals2
- FINALOrioles7Phillies2
- FINALBrewers4Tigers10
- FINALRays3Mets5
- FINALBraves8Red Sox2
- FINALWhite Sox3Reds4
- FINALYankees5Marlins1
- FINALCardinals10Royals5
- FINALAstros2Twins5
- FINALPirates3Rockies7
- FINALDodgers4Angels5
- FINALAthletics7Padres5
- FINALD-backs3Mariners4
- FINALRangers4Giants6