Fri June 26, 2009
- FINALCubs5White Sox4
- FINALReds2Guardians9
- FINALNationals1Orioles11
- FINALRoyals3Pirates5
- FINALPhillies1Blue Jays6
- FINALYankees9Mets1
- FINALRed Sox4Braves1
- FINALMarlins3Rays7
- FINALTigers4Astros5
- FINALPadres2Rangers12
- FINALGiants1Brewers5
- FINALTwins3Cardinals1
- FINALAngels12D-backs3
- FINALRockies4Athletics2
- FINALMariners2Dodgers8