Fri July 3, 2009
- FINALBlue Jays2Yankees4
- FINAL/10Brewers1Cubs2
- FINALPirates7Marlins4
- FINALBraves9Nationals8
- FINALAthletics3Guardians15
- FINALMets2Phillies7
- FINAL/11Mariners7Red Sox6
- FINALCardinals7Reds4
- FINALRays1Rangers3
- FINALD-backs0Rockies5
- FINAL/16Tigers11Twins9
- FINALWhite Sox5Royals0
- FINALOrioles6Angels4
- FINALDodgers6Padres3
- FINALAstros0Giants13