Wed July 22, 2009
- FINALBrewers7Pirates8
- FINALCubs10Phillies5
- FINALOrioles4Yankees6
- FINALD-backs3Rockies4
- FINALTwins1Athletics16
- FINALMarlins5Padres0
- FINALGiants2Braves4
- FINALMets1Nationals3
- FINALMariners2Tigers1
- FINALGuardians6Blue Jays10
- FINALCardinals3Astros4
- FINALRed Sox1Rangers3
- FINALAngels9Royals6
- FINALRays3White Sox4
- FINALReds2Dodgers6