Wed August 12, 2009
- FINAL/11Blue Jays3Yankees4
- FINALAthletics6Orioles3
- FINALRays5Angels10
- FINALMets6D-backs4
- FINAL/10Dodgers2Giants4
- FINALNationals2Braves6
- FINALRangers5Guardians0
- FINALTigers2Red Sox8
- FINALAstros14Marlins6
- FINALPhillies12Cubs5
- FINALPadres6Brewers5
- FINALRoyals1Twins7
- FINALReds2Cardinals5
- FINALPirates0Rockies8
- FINAL/14White Sox0Mariners1