Tue August 18, 2009
- FINALAngels5Guardians4
- FINALRockies4Nationals3
- FINALMariners3Tigers5
- FINALD-backs1Phillies5
- FINALBrewers2Pirates5
- FINALRed Sox10Blue Jays9
- FINALOrioles4Rays5
- FINAL/10Giants8Reds5
- FINALBraves4Mets9
- FINALTwins9Rangers6
- FINALMarlins6Astros2
- FINALRoyals5White Sox4
- FINALCubs3Padres6
- FINALYankees7Athletics2
- FINALCardinals3Dodgers7