Fri September 4, 2009
- FINALCardinals14Pirates7
- FINALRangers5Orioles1
- FINALTwins2Guardians5
- FINALMarlins9Nationals6
- FINALYankees0Blue Jays6
- FINALCubs2Mets6
- FINALReds3Braves1
- FINALTigers4Rays3
- FINALPhillies0Astros7
- FINALGiants3Brewers2
- FINALAngels2Royals1
- FINALRed Sox2White Sox12
- FINALD-backs4Rockies5
- FINALMariners6Athletics3
- FINALPadres2Dodgers0