Wed September 16, 2009
- FINAL
Guardians3
Twins7 - FINAL
Marlins5
Cardinals2 - FINAL
Pirates1
Dodgers3 - FINAL/10
D-backs5
Padres6 - FINAL
Mets5
Braves6 - FINAL
Royals3
Tigers4 - FINAL
Rays2
Orioles4 - FINAL
Nationals1
Phillies6 - FINAL
Blue Jays4
Yankees5 - FINAL
Angels8
Red Sox9 - FINAL
Astros5
Reds6 - FINAL
Athletics4
Rangers0 - FINAL
Brewers9
Cubs5 - FINAL
White Sox1
Mariners4 - FINAL
Rockies4
Giants3
