Wed September 23, 2009
- FINAL
Yankees3
Angels2 - FINAL
Tigers11
Guardians3 - FINAL
Dodgers4
Nationals5 - FINAL
Reds12
Pirates2 - FINAL
Orioles3
Blue Jays7 - FINAL
Mariners4
Rays5 - FINAL
Braves5
Mets2 - FINAL
Phillies6
Marlins7 - FINAL
Cardinals0
Astros3 - FINAL
Cubs2
Brewers3 - FINAL
Red Sox9
Royals2 - FINAL
Twins8
White Sox6 - FINAL
Padres6
Rockies3 - FINAL
Rangers9
Athletics8 - FINAL
Giants5
D-backs2
