Tue September 7, 1999
- Game 1FINALReds1Cubs2
- FINALRockies1Nationals4
- FINALPadres1Pirates3
- FINALAstros8Phillies6
- FINALDodgers1Marlins2
- FINALGiants7Mets4
- Game 2FINALReds10Cubs3
- FINALCardinals2Braves3
- FINALGuardians3Rangers4
- FINALOrioles5Twins0
- FINALYankees3Royals6
- FINALD-backs11Brewers9
- FINALRed Sox5Athletics3
- FINALBlue Jays4Mariners7
- FINALWhite Sox1Angels14