Wed September 8, 1999
- FINALRockies5Nationals1
- FINAL/10Padres7Pirates4
- FINALGiants5Mets7
- FINALReds6Cubs4
- FINALRed Sox2Athletics6
- FINAL/13Dodgers4Marlins5
- FINALTigers5Rays1
- FINALAstros10Phillies2
- FINALCardinals4Braves5
- FINALGuardians0Rangers3
- FINALOrioles10Twins0
- FINALYankees9Royals5
- FINALD-backs9Brewers1
- FINALBlue Jays3Mariners4
- FINAL/10White Sox5Angels6