Fri September 17, 1999
- FINAL/10Brewers5Cubs6
- FINALTigers3Red Sox14
- FINALReds1Pirates3
- FINALWhite Sox7Blue Jays3
- FINALYankees9Guardians4
- FINALPhillies8Mets5
- FINAL/10Nationals5Braves6
- FINALDodgers10Rockies18
- FINALRays7Rangers5
- FINALAstros8Cardinals11
- FINALMarlins10D-backs6
- FINALOrioles4Angels2
- FINALGiants4Padres2
- FINALTwins3Mariners4
- FINALRoyals9Athletics3