Sat September 18, 1999
- FINALYankees4Guardians5
- FINALReds3Pirates0
- FINALAstros6Cardinals13
- FINALDodgers5Rockies4
- FINALTigers1Red Sox9
- FINALRoyals4Athletics8
- FINALWhite Sox7Blue Jays4
- FINAL/10Marlins6D-backs8
- FINAL/14Brewers7Cubs4
- FINALGiants5Padres11
- FINALPhillies1Mets11
- FINALNationals4Braves3
- FINALRays1Rangers6
- FINALTwins0Mariners5
- FINALOrioles6Angels3