Sun September 19, 1999
- FINALTigers3Red Sox7
- FINALWhite Sox3Blue Jays2
- FINALYankees11Guardians7
- FINALNationals1Braves5
- FINALReds5Pirates8
- FINALPhillies6Mets8
- FINALAstros4Cardinals3
- FINAL/10Brewers7Cubs8
- FINALDodgers5Rockies2
- FINALRays15Rangers2
- FINALRoyals3Athletics12
- FINALMarlins7D-backs8
- FINALTwins2Mariners1
- FINALOrioles5Angels4
- FINALGiants3Padres6