Fri September 24, 1999
- FINALPirates0Cubs9
- FINALOrioles1Red Sox0
- FINALRoyals7Tigers3
- FINALCardinals4Reds5
- FINALGuardians18Blue Jays4
- FINALMets2Phillies3
- FINAL/10Braves4Nationals3
- FINALRockies5Marlins3
- FINAL/11Rays3Yankees4
- FINALAthletics4Rangers12
- FINALWhite Sox2Twins6
- FINALAstros9Brewers4
- FINAL/10Angels3Mariners4
- FINALPadres1Dodgers5
- FINALD-backs11Giants3