Sat September 25, 1999
- FINALCardinals1Reds6
- FINALMets2Phillies4
- FINALOrioles1Red Sox4
- FINALPirates1Cubs3
- FINALD-backs7Giants3
- FINALGuardians9Blue Jays6
- FINALRays2Yankees1
- FINALRoyals3Tigers11
- FINALBraves5Nationals3
- FINALRockies2Marlins8
- FINALAthletics4Rangers10
- FINALWhite Sox13Twins4
- FINALAstros2Brewers3
- FINALAngels7Mariners3
- FINALPadres3Dodgers2