Tue May 3, 2005
- FINALRed Sox5Tigers3
- FINALBlue Jays1Orioles0
- FINALCardinals4Reds2
- FINALPhillies10Mets3
- FINALYankees4Rays11
- FINALMarlins11Braves6
- FINALPirates7Astros4
- FINALRoyals4White Sox5
- FINALCubs1Brewers4
- FINALGuardians4Twins2
- FINALGiants2D-backs3
- FINALRockies1Padres2
- FINALAngels5Mariners2
- FINALRangers6Athletics1
- FINALNationals2Dodgers4