Wed May 4, 2005
- FINALMarlins2Braves5
- FINALBlue Jays1Orioles5
- FINAL/12Rockies7Padres8
- FINALRangers16Athletics7
- FINALGiants2D-backs6
- FINALAngels5Mariners2
- FINALRed Sox4Tigers3
- FINALCardinals7Reds3
- FINALPhillies2Mets3
- FINALYankees8Rays11
- FINALPirates6Astros4
- FINALRoyals2White Sox4
- FINALCubs3Brewers4
- FINALGuardians5Twins4
- FINALNationals5Dodgers2