Fri September 9, 2005
- FINALRoyals12Tigers2
- FINALTwins2Guardians4
- FINALBraves6Nationals8
- FINALMarlins5Phillies12
- FINALRed Sox4Yankees8
- FINALPirates8Reds4
- FINALBlue Jays7Rays2
- FINALAthletics9Rangers8
- FINAL/12Angels6White Sox5
- FINALAstros4Brewers7
- FINALMets2Cardinals3
- FINALD-backs7Rockies1
- FINALOrioles2Mariners3
- FINALCubs1Giants2
- FINALPadres3Dodgers1