Sat September 10, 2005
- FINALOrioles5Mariners3
- FINALD-backs8Rockies5
- FINALAthletics5Rangers4
- FINALMets2Cardinals4
- FINALPirates2Reds6
- FINALRoyals3Tigers4
- FINALTwins5Guardians7
- FINALMarlins7Phillies6
- FINALAstros7Brewers5
- FINALBlue Jays3Rays2
- FINALPadres1Dodgers3
- FINALCubs5Giants2
- FINALBraves4Nationals0
- FINALRed Sox9Yankees2
- FINALAngels10White Sox5