Fri April 10, 2009
- POSTPONEDPiratesReds
- FINALRangers2Tigers15
- FINALBlue Jays13Guardians7
- FINALCubs3Brewers4
- FINALPhillies3Rockies10
- FINALYankees4Royals1
- FINALRays4Orioles5
- FINALMets4Marlins5
- FINAL/10Nationals5Braves6
- FINALTwins12White Sox5
- FINALAstros3Cardinals5
- FINALDodgers4D-backs9
- FINALRed Sox3Angels6
- FINALMariners5Athletics4
- FINALGiants3Padres7