Sat April 11, 2009
- FINALRangers3Tigers4
- FINALBlue Jays5Guardians4
- FINALPirates10Reds2
- FINALMariners8Athletics5
- FINALTwins0White Sox8
- FINALRed Sox5Angels4
- FINALAstros2Cardinals11
- FINALMets8Marlins4
- FINALNationals3Braves5
- FINALRays0Orioles6
- FINALCubs6Brewers5
- FINALYankees6Royals1
- FINALDodgers11D-backs2
- FINALPhillies8Rockies4
- FINALGiants3Padres6