Fri April 17, 2009
- FINALGuardians5Yankees6
- FINALCardinals7Cubs8
- FINALPadres8Phillies7
- FINALBraves0Pirates3
- FINAL/10Marlins3Nationals2
- FINALAthletics8Blue Jays5
- FINALOrioles8Red Sox10
- FINALBrewers4Mets5
- FINALWhite Sox5Rays6
- FINALReds2Astros1
- FINALRoyals12Rangers3
- FINALAngels9Twins11
- FINALRockies3Dodgers4
- FINALTigers3Mariners6
- FINALD-backs0Giants2