Sat April 18, 2009
- FINALBraves0Pirates10
- FINAL/11Marlins9Nationals6
- FINAL/12Athletics2Blue Jays4
- FINALBrewers0Mets1
- FINALRockies5Dodgers9
- FINAL/11Cardinals5Cubs7
- FINALGuardians22Yankees4
- FINALD-backs2Giants0
- FINALReds0Astros7
- FINALPadres8Phillies5
- FINALWhite Sox8Rays3
- FINALOrioles4Red Sox6
- FINALAngels2Twins9
- FINALRoyals2Rangers0
- FINALTigers2Mariners0