Tue April 21, 2009
- POSTPONEDTwinsRed Sox
- FINALRoyals7Guardians8
- FINALBraves3Nationals4
- FINALWhite Sox3Orioles10
- FINALMarlins2Pirates3
- FINALAthletics3Yankees5
- FINALBrewers4Phillies11
- FINALRangers5Blue Jays4
- FINALReds2Cubs7
- FINALDodgers5Astros8
- FINALMets4Cardinals6
- FINALRockies9D-backs6
- FINALTigers3Angels4
- FINALRays2Mariners4
- FINALPadres3Giants8