Wed April 22, 2009
- FINALTwins1Red Sox10
- FINALMarlins4Pirates7
- FINAL/14Athletics7Yankees9
- FINALRockies0D-backs2
- FINAL/10Padres0Giants1
- FINALRoyals2Guardians0
- FINALBraves1Nationals0
- FINALWhite Sox8Orioles2
- FINALBrewers3Phillies1
- FINAL/11Rangers7Blue Jays8
- FINALTwins3Red Sox7
- FINALReds3Cubs0
- FINALDodgers5Astros6
- FINALMets2Cardinals5
- FINALTigers12Angels10
- FINALRays9Mariners3