Mon May 4, 2009
- FINALMets6Braves4
- FINALAstros4Nationals9
- FINALTwins7Tigers2
- FINALRed Sox6Yankees4
- FINALBrewers7Pirates4
- FINAL/12Guardians9Blue Jays7
- FINALOrioles8Rays4
- FINAL/14Reds2Marlins3
- FINALGiants2Cubs4
- FINALWhite Sox0Royals3
- FINALPhillies6Cardinals1
- FINALAngels5Athletics2
- FINALRockies9Padres6
- FINALD-backs2Dodgers7
- FINALRangers6Mariners5