Tue May 5, 2009
- FINAL/11Astros10Nationals11
- FINALGuardians6Blue Jays10
- FINALGiants6Cubs2
- FINALOrioles3Rays6
- FINAL/10Rangers7Mariners2
- FINALMets4Braves3
- FINALTwins0Tigers9
- FINALRed Sox7Yankees3
- FINALBrewers8Pirates5
- FINALReds7Marlins0
- FINAL/11White Sox7Royals8
- FINALPhillies10Cardinals7
- FINALAngels5Athletics3
- FINAL/10Rockies1Padres2
- FINALD-backs1Dodgers3