Tue May 12, 2009
- FINALCardinals1Pirates7
- FINALRays5Orioles7
- FINALDodgers3Phillies5
- FINALWhite Sox7Guardians4
- FINALYankees1Blue Jays5
- FINAL/10Braves3Mets4
- FINALPadres2Cubs6
- FINALMariners1Rangers7
- FINALMarlins3Brewers6
- FINALTigers2Twins6
- FINALAstros1Rockies12
- FINALReds3D-backs1
- FINALRed Sox4Angels3
- FINALRoyals3Athletics12
- FINALNationals7Giants9