Wed May 13, 2009
- FINALWhite Sox0Guardians4
- FINAL/12Braves8Mets7
- FINALNationals6Giants3
- FINALCardinals2Pirates5
- FINALRays8Orioles6
- FINALDodgers9Phillies2
- FINALYankees8Blue Jays2
- FINALPadres4Cubs6
- FINAL/11Mariners5Rangers6
- FINALMarlins6Brewers8
- FINAL/13Tigers10Twins14
- FINALAstros15Rockies11
- FINALReds10D-backs3
- FINALRed Sox4Angels8
- FINALRoyals2Athletics7