Tue May 19, 2009
- FINALRockies1Braves8
- FINAL/10Pirates8Nationals5
- FINALRangers0Tigers4
- FINALOrioles1Yankees9
- FINAL/11Athletics4Rays1
- FINALBlue Jays1Red Sox2
- FINALPhillies4Reds3
- FINALD-backs5Marlins3
- FINALBrewers4Astros2
- FINALGuardians5Royals6
- FINALTwins2White Sox6
- FINALCubs0Cardinals3
- FINALGiants1Padres2
- FINALMets3Dodgers5
- FINALAngels6Mariners5