Wed May 20, 2009
- Game 1FINALD-backs6Marlins8
- Game 2FINAL/13D-backs11Marlins9
- FINALRockies4Braves12
- FINALPirates2Nationals1
- FINALRangers3Tigers5
- FINALOrioles4Yankees11
- FINALAthletics7Rays6
- FINALBlue Jays3Red Sox8
- FINALPhillies1Reds5
- FINALBrewers4Astros6
- FINALGuardians6Royals5
- FINALTwins4White Sox7
- FINALCubs1Cardinals2
- FINALGiants1Padres2
- FINALMets1Dodgers2
- FINALAngels0Mariners1