Sat May 23, 2009
- FINALRoyals0Cardinals5
- FINALRangers6Astros3
- FINALPhillies4Yankees5
- FINALBlue Jays3Braves4
- FINALRockies4Tigers3
- FINALOrioles2Nationals1
- FINALPirates0White Sox4
- FINALGuardians7Reds6
- FINALMets3Red Sox2
- FINALRays10Marlins3
- FINALBrewers2Twins6
- FINAL/11D-backs8Athletics7
- FINALCubs1Padres3
- FINAL/10Angels4Dodgers5
- FINALGiants5Mariners1